O'Reilly Automotive, Inc.

Based on the provided analysis, here is an assessment of whether O'Reilly Automotive (ORLY) is worth buying.

Technical Analysis: ORLY is in a clear downtrend, having underperformed the market significantly over the last three months. The stock is currently positioned in the middle of its 52-week range, suggesting a lack of strong directional momentum. The persistent negative price action indicates ongoing selling pressure that has yet to subside.

Fundamentals: The company's underlying business remains strong, characterized by high profitability and excellent operational efficiency. While quarterly margins saw slight pressure, the core model is healthy, evidenced by a negative cash conversion cycle that highlights superior working capital management. The use of leverage is significant but appears manageable given solid interest coverage.

Valuation & Risk: The primary concern is ORLY's premium valuation, with elevated P/E and EV/EBITDA multiples suggesting high growth expectations are already priced in. While its low beta offers a defensive characteristic with reduced volatility, the stock carries valuation risk if its growth trajectory fails to meet investor expectations.

Buy Recommendation:

O'Reilly Automotive operates a fundamentally sound and profitable business with defensive qualities. However, the stock's current premium valuation leaves little room for error, and it is technically weak with no clear signs of a reversal. For investors with a long-term horizon, waiting for a more attractive entry point—either through a price correction or a confirmed technical recovery—would be prudent. The strong business model is compelling, but the risk/reward profile at current levels is not optimal for a new purchase.

RockFlow Model Forecast: Three Scenarios for 2026

Based on O'Reilly Automotive's (ORLY) strong fundamentals but challenging technical and valuation picture, the 12-month outlook is cautiously optimistic with a reliance on execution.

Key Catalysts: The primary driver will be the company's ability to consistently meet or exceed high earnings expectations, demonstrating resilience against any consumer softness. Its defensive, non-discretionary business model should continue to provide stable cash flow, potentially rewarding investors if market volatility increases.

Potential Risks: The most significant risk is a de-rating of its premium valuation if same-store sales growth decelerates or margins compress more than anticipated. Furthermore, the persistent technical downtrend suggests investor skepticism that must be overcome with strong quarterly results.

Target Price Range: Given the high valuation and lack of a provided analyst target, a conservative 12-month price target would be in the range of $100-$110. This represents modest upside from the current price of $92.6, contingent on the company successfully navigating the current pressures and justifying its premium multiple.

Wall Street Consensus

Most Wall Street analysts are optimistic about O'Reilly Automotive, Inc.'s 12-month outlook, with consensus target around $94.17, indicating expected upside potential.

Overall, ORLY has investment potential but also faces challenges. Here are key factors to weigh before investing.

ORLY has demonstrated weak performance over recent months, trading well below its 52-week highs amid broader market underperformance.

The stock declined 1.11% over one month and 6.67% over three months, significantly underperforming the market by 6.65% during the latter period despite its low beta indicating typically lower volatility. This consistent negative momentum suggests persistent selling pressure rather than temporary weakness.

Currently trading at $92.60, ORLY sits approximately 15% above its 52-week low but remains nearly 15% below its yearly peak, indicating it's neither severely oversold nor overbought. The 16.21% maximum drawdown reflects moderate downside volatility within a generally weak trend.

Revenue & Profitability: O'Reilly's Q4 revenue of $4.41 billion reflects a slight sequential decrease from Q3's $4.71 billion, though profitability remains strong with a gross profit margin of 51.8%. Operating and net income margins showed a modest sequential contraction to 18.8% and 13.7%, respectively, indicating consistent but slightly pressured profitability in the quarter.

Financial Health: The company's debt ratio stands at 63.6%, reflecting a significant use of leverage, though this is supported by a solid interest coverage ratio of 13.7x. The negative cash conversion cycle of -47 days is a notable strength, indicating efficient working capital management where the company is funded by its suppliers.

Operational Efficiency: While return on assets is a modest 3.7%, the negative return on equity is distorted by negative shareholder equity, making it less meaningful. Operational efficiency is more accurately reflected in the respectable return on capital employed of 10.7% and an asset turnover of 0.27, indicating solid utilization of capital to generate sales.

Valuation Level: O'Reilly Automotive exhibits elevated valuation levels across multiple metrics that suggest investor optimism may be pricing in significant future growth. The TTM and Forward P/E ratios both surpassing 30 indicate a premium valuation, which is further underscored by an exceptionally high EV/EBITDA of 90.6. The negative PEG and P/B ratios, while mathematically concerning due to accounting treatment of share repurchases, do not negate the clear premium suggested by the earnings-based multiples.

Peer Comparison: Without specific industry average data, a definitive peer comparison cannot be established. However, given the automotive retail sector typically trades at more moderate earnings multiples, ORLY's P/E above 30 likely positions it at a significant premium to industry peers. This valuation gap suggests the market is awarding O'Reilly a quality or growth premium that may not be fully reflected in standard sector benchmarks.

Volatility Risk: ORLY exhibits low volatility risk relative to the broader market, evidenced by its beta of 0.616. This indicates the stock is approximately 38% less volatile, which is further corroborated by a modest one-year maximum drawdown of -16.21%. While moderate, this drawdown still represents a quantifiable risk for investors, albeit lower than more volatile equities.

Other Risks: The absence of reported short interest suggests minimal speculative pressure or negative sentiment from short sellers. However, investors should remain aware of sector-specific risks, such as economic sensitivity impacting consumer spending on auto parts, and overall market liquidity, which can affect trade execution.