CarMax
KMX
$54.86
-0.11%
CarMax Inc. is the largest used-vehicle retailer in the United States, operating roughly 260 retail stores and selling, financing, and servicing used and new cars, with used-vehicle sales representing about 80% of fiscal 2026 revenue and wholesale operations contributing roughly 17%. The company is a scaled omnichannel platform in the highly fragmented auto-dealership industry, pairing its physical store network with digital tools like instant online appraisals and home delivery, though it still commands only about 3.6% of the US market for vehicles zero to 10 years old, leaving substantial runway for share gains. The current investor narrative centers on a turnaround and margin-recovery story: after a loss-making fiscal fourth quarter, CarMax posted a strong fiscal Q2 2027 with 19.5% revenue growth and $1.16 in diluted EPS, prompting headlines questioning whether the stock is now a buy. Debate is intensifying around whether the earnings rebound is durable given softer forward guidance, elevated interest rates pressuring its credit-sensitive customer base, and a consensus analyst stance that remains firmly neutral.…
KMX
CarMax
$54.86
Related headlines
Investment Opinion: Should I buy KMX Today?
The synthesized recommendation is Hold. CarMax is a turnaround story with improving revenue growth and cash flow, but its core retail operations remain unprofitable on an operating basis, and the analyst consensus is neutral with a mean rating of 2.85. The average target price of $62.62 implies 14% upside, which is not compelling enough to offset the risks.
The supporting evidence is mixed. On the positive side, revenue grew 19.46% year-over-year in fiscal Q2 2027, EPS swung to $1.16 from a loss, and free cash flow is strong at $1.146 billion trailing. The valuation is cheap on sales (0.246x) and book (1.08x), and the forward PE of 17.78x is reasonable if earnings materialize. However, operating margin is negative at -1.58%, debt-to-equity is high at 3.02x, and the stock has recently underperformed the market by 11.19% over one month.
The biggest risks are the sustainability of the earnings recovery, high leverage, and competitive pressures. The rating would upgrade to Buy if operating margins turn sustainably positive and revenue growth remains above 15%, or downgrade to Sell if operating margins fail to improve and revenue growth decelerates below 10%. Relative to its history and peers, the stock appears fairly valued to slightly undervalued on book value but expensive on trailing earnings.
Sign up to view all
KMX 12-Month Price Forecast
CarMax is a show-me story with improving top-line growth and cash flow, but its core profitability remains weak. The valuation is not demanding on a forward basis, but the high leverage and competitive pressures warrant caution. The neutral stance reflects the balance between potential upside from margin recovery and downside risks from execution missteps. An upgrade to bullish would require sustained positive operating margins and revenue growth above 15%; a downgrade to bearish would occur if operating margins fail to improve or revenue growth stalls.
Wall Street consensus
Most Wall Street analysts maintain a constructive view on CarMax's 12-month outlook, with a consensus price target around $62.62 and implied upside of +14.1% versus the current price.
Average Target
$62.62
0 analysts
Implied Upside
+14.1%
vs. current price
Analyst Count
—
covering this stock
Price Range
$43 - $96
Analyst target range
CarMax is covered by 13 analysts, and the consensus recommendation is a hold with a recommendation mean of 2.85, leaning neutral-to-cautious. The average price target is $62.62, which implies roughly 14.0% upside from the current price of $54.92. The distribution of recent institutional ratings is notably mixed: Baird and Stephens & Co. carry Outperform/Overweight ratings, while BNP Paribas and B of A Securities maintain Underperform ratings, and the majority of firms (Truist, RBC Capital, Morgan Stanley, JP Morgan) sit at Hold/Neutral/Equal Weight. This split reflects genuine disagreement about whether the earnings recovery is sustainable, and the consensus hold stance suggests the market is not yet convinced the turnaround deserves a higher multiple. The target range is exceptionally wide, from a low of $43.00 to a high of $96.00, a spread of more than 2x the current price. The high target of $96.00 implies roughly 75% upside and would require a full margin-recovery story: sustained double-digit revenue growth, normalization of operating margins toward historical levels, and multiple expansion as the market re-rates the stock. The low target of $43.00 implies about 22% downside and likely prices in margin compression, weakening consumer demand under elevated interest rates, and competitive pressure from digital rivals like Carvana. The wide spread signals high uncertainty and low conviction among analysts, which is consistent with the recent pattern of ratings activity: JP Morgan upgraded from Underweight to Neutral in late July, but most firms have simply reiterated existing stances rather than making bold calls. With estimated EPS ranging from $3.21 to $5.49 and estimated revenue from $28.9 billion to $31.4 billion, the dispersion in fundamental forecasts mirrors the dispersion in price targets, reinforcing that this is a show-me story where execution over the next several quarters will determine whether the bulls or bears prevail.
Bulls vs Bears: KMX Investment Factors
The bull case rests on CarMax's strong revenue reacceleration (19.46% YoY), positive EPS swing, and robust free cash flow, supported by a low price-to-book ratio of 1.08x and analyst target upside of 14%. The bear case highlights persistent negative operating margins (-1.58% trailing), high leverage (debt-to-equity of 3.02x), and recent negative momentum (-10.60% over one month). Currently, the bear evidence appears slightly stronger because the core retail operations are not yet profitable on an operating basis, and the recent pullback suggests waning investor confidence. The single most important tension is whether the earnings recovery is durable: if operating margins normalize toward historical levels, the stock could re-rate significantly; if not, the low price-to-book offers limited downside cushion given the high leverage.
Bullish
- Revenue growth reaccelerated sharply: Fiscal Q2 2027 revenue reached $7.878 billion, up 19.46% year-over-year from $6.595 billion, marking a decisive rebound from the loss-making fiscal Q4 2026. This double-digit growth confirms that the core used-vehicle business is regaining momentum after a seasonally weak quarter.
- Profitability swung back positive: Net income of $165.3 million and diluted EPS of $1.16 in fiscal Q2 2027 reversed the fiscal Q4 2026 net loss of $120.7 million (-$0.77 per share). The swing demonstrates operating leverage as volumes recover.
- Free cash flow turned strongly positive: Free cash flow was $805.8 million in fiscal Q2 2027 and $1.146 billion on a trailing basis, a dramatic improvement from -$687.3 million in fiscal Q4 2026. This cash generation provides flexibility to fund operations and reduce leverage.
- Valuation cheap on sales and book: The price-to-sales ratio of 0.246x and price-to-book of 1.08x are low in absolute terms and near the low end of CarMax's historical range (PB historically 0.95x to over 4.4x). The forward PE of 17.78x is reasonable if consensus EPS of $4.22 is achieved.
Bearish
- Operating margin remains negative: The trailing operating margin is -1.58%, and even the latest quarterly operating income of $236.3 million equates to just a 3.00% operating margin. Profitability is heavily dependent on interest income and other non-operating items, not core retail operations.
- High leverage amplifies risk: Debt-to-equity stands at 3.02x with a debt ratio of roughly 68.6%, reflecting the capital-intensive, floorplan-financed nature of auto retailing. This leverage magnifies downside if demand stalls or interest rates remain elevated.
- Recent momentum has turned negative: The stock is down 10.60% over the past month and has underperformed the S&P 500 by 11.19% in that period, despite being up 39.78% year-to-date. This sharp deceleration suggests the recovery trade is losing steam.
- Analyst consensus is neutral: The consensus recommendation is hold with a mean of 2.85, and ratings are split between Outperform (Baird, Stephens) and Underperform (BNP Paribas, B of A). The wide target range of $43 to $96 signals low conviction and high uncertainty.
KMX Technical Analysis
CarMax is in a broad recovery uptrend that has stalled in recent weeks. The stock is up 19.21% over the past year and 39.78% year-to-date, trading at roughly $54.92, which places it at about 71% of its 52-week range between a low of $30.26 and a high of $65.28. That positioning signals the stock has reclaimed substantial ground from its lows but is not yet at momentum-driven overextension, leaving room before it challenges the upper boundary of its range. Short-term momentum, however, has turned negative and diverges sharply from the longer-term trend. The stock is down 10.60% over the past month versus a 7.73% gain over three months and a 33.20% gain over six months, indicating a clear deceleration after a strong spring and summer run. Relative strength versus the S&P 500 tells the same story: -11.19% over one month against +4.39% over three months and +15.85% over six months, meaning CarMax has materially lagged the market in the last 30 days even as it outperformed over the prior half-year. This divergence looks like a sharp pullback or mean-reversion phase within a still-intact recovery rather than a confirmed trend reversal, though the magnitude of the one-month underperformance warrants caution. Key technical levels are well defined by the 52-week range. Support sits near the $30.26 52-week low, with more immediate psychological support around the $50 area where the stock consolidated in July; resistance is anchored at the $65.28 52-week high, and a breakout above that level would confirm renewed momentum and likely invite trend-following capital. A breakdown below $50 would suggest the recent pullback is deepening and could expose the mid-$40s. With a beta of 1.171, CarMax is roughly 17% more volatile than the broader market, and its maximum drawdown of -50.33% underscores that this is a high-risk, cyclically sensitive name where position sizing and stop discipline matter considerably.
Beta
1.23
1.23x market volatility
Max Drawdown
-49.7%
Largest decline past year
52-Week Range
$30-$65
Price range past year
Annual Return
+18.2%
Cumulative gain past year
| Period | KMX Return | S&P 500 |
|---|---|---|
| 1m | -13.3% | +0.6% |
| 3m | +7.5% | +3.6% |
| 6m | +24.0% | +14.6% |
| 1y | +18.2% | +15.8% |
| ytd | +39.6% | +13.6% |
Bobby - Your AI Investment Partner
Get real-time data, AI-driven personalized investment analysis to make smarter investment decisions
KMX Fundamental Analysis
CarMax's revenue trajectory has reaccelerated meaningfully. Fiscal Q2 2027 revenue reached $7.878 billion, up 19.46% year-over-year, a sharp improvement from the $6.595 billion reported in the year-ago quarter. Sequentially, revenue has climbed from $5.946 billion in fiscal Q4 2026 to $8.014 billion in Q1 2027 and $7.878 billion in Q2 2027, showing a strong rebound after a seasonally weak fourth quarter. Segment data shows used vehicles generating $6.311 billion and wholesale vehicles $1.359 billion, confirming that the core used-car business is the primary growth engine. The key question for the investment case is whether this double-digit growth reflects durable market-share gains and improved vehicle affordability or merely easier comparisons and wholesale price inflation. Profitability has swung decisively back into positive territory after a loss-making quarter. Fiscal Q2 2027 net income was $165.3 million with diluted EPS of $1.16, a dramatic reversal from the fiscal Q4 2026 net loss of $120.7 million (-$0.77 per share). Gross margin in the latest quarter was 10.15%, consistent with the roughly 10.0%-10.2% range seen across recent quarters, indicating stable but structurally thin retail margins typical of the used-vehicle dealership industry. Operating margin, however, remains a concern: the trailing operating margin is -1.58% and the latest quarterly operating income of $236.3 million equates to a 3.00% operating margin, showing that profitability is heavily dependent on interest income and other non-operating items rather than core retail operations. The balance sheet carries meaningful leverage but also improving cash generation. Debt-to-equity stands at 3.02x, and the debt ratio of roughly 68.6% reflects the capital-intensive, floorplan-financed nature of auto retailing. Free cash flow turned strongly positive at $805.8 million in fiscal Q2 2027 and $1.146 billion on a trailing basis, a major improvement from the -$687.3 million FCF in fiscal Q4 2026. The current ratio of 2.20 indicates adequate short-term liquidity, while ROE of just 4.20% and ROA of 1.78% remain low, reflecting compressed profitability relative to the company's asset base. The critical takeaway is that CarMax is now generating enough internal cash to fund operations and capex, but its high leverage and thin returns mean financial risk remains elevated if the demand recovery stalls.
Quarterly Revenue
$7.9B
2026-08
Revenue YoY Growth
+19.5%
YoY Comparison
Gross Margin
10.2%
Latest Quarter
Free Cash Flow
$1.1B
Last 12 Months
Revenue & Net Income Trends (2 Years)
Revenue Breakdown
Open an Account, get $2 TSLA now!
Valuation Analysis: Is KMX Overvalued?
Because CarMax is profitable on a trailing basis with positive net income, the PE ratio is the appropriate primary metric. The stock trades at a trailing PE of 25.70x versus a forward PE of 17.78x, a gap of roughly 31% that implies the market expects earnings to grow substantially over the next year. That expectation is supported by consensus estimated EPS of $4.22 versus trailing EPS of just $0.04, reflecting the anticipated normalization of profitability after the loss-making fiscal Q4 2026. The forward multiple is the more economically meaningful figure here, as trailing earnings are depressed by one weak quarter. On peer and sector comparison, CarMax screens cheap on several measures. Its price-to-sales ratio of 0.246x and price-to-book of 1.08x are low in absolute terms, and its EV/Sales of 0.87x and EV/EBITDA of 14.93x suggest the market is not paying a large premium for the business. However, the trailing PE of 25.70x is elevated relative to the company's own history, and the PEG ratio of -0.54 is not meaningful given the earnings volatility. The forward PE of 17.78x is the key comparison point: if CarMax can deliver the consensus $4.22 in EPS, the stock is trading at a reasonable multiple for a market leader with 19% revenue growth, but any shortfall would quickly make the valuation look stretched. Historically, CarMax's PE has ranged widely, from roughly 8.6x in fiscal Q1 2027 to over 60x in loss-affected periods, with the current trailing 25.70x sitting in the middle-to-upper portion of that band. Its price-to-book of 1.08x, by contrast, is near the low end of its multi-year range, which historically has ranged from about 0.95x to over 4.4x, suggesting the market is pricing in substantial skepticism about returns on equity. The combination of a mid-range PE and a near-historical-low PB implies the market expects earnings recovery but does not yet believe CarMax can restore its former levels of profitability and return on capital. This creates an asymmetric setup: if margins normalize, both earnings and the multiple could expand, but if the recovery stalls, the low PB offers only limited downside cushion given the company's high leverage.
PE
25.7x
Latest Quarter
vs. Historical
Mid-Range
5-Year PE Range 9x~39x
vs. Industry Avg
N/A
Industry PE ~N/A*
EV/EBITDA
14.9x
Enterprise Value Multiple
Investment Risk Disclosure
CarMax faces significant financial and operational risks. The company carries a debt-to-equity ratio of 3.02x and a debt ratio of 68.6%, reflecting its capital-intensive, floorplan-financed model. Operating margin is negative at -1.58% on a trailing basis, and even the latest quarter's 3.00% operating margin is heavily reliant on interest income rather than core retail profitability. With gross margins thin at 10.15%, any compression in vehicle pricing or slowdown in demand could quickly erode earnings. Additionally, revenue is concentrated in used vehicles (80% of fiscal 2026 revenue), making the company vulnerable to cyclical swings in the used-car market.
Market and competitive risks are also pronounced. CarMax trades at a trailing PE of 25.70x, which is elevated relative to its own history, and a forward PE of 17.78x that leaves little room for earnings misses. The stock's beta of 1.171 indicates it is about 17% more volatile than the broader market, and its maximum drawdown of -50.33% underscores its sensitivity to economic cycles. Competition from digital rivals like Carvana and traditional dealers is intensifying, and elevated interest rates continue to pressure the credit-sensitive customer base. Recent news highlights that high interest rates disproportionately affect Carvana's customer base, a dynamic that applies equally to CarMax.
The worst-case scenario would involve a sustained slowdown in used-vehicle demand, margin compression, and a failure to achieve consensus EPS of $4.22. In this scenario, the stock could retest its 52-week low of $30.26, representing a decline of approximately 45% from the current price of $54.92. The analyst low target of $43.00 implies a 22% downside, but a more severe outcome could see the stock fall to the low $30s if operating losses persist and leverage becomes a concern. Investors could lose 20-45% of their capital in such an adverse scenario.
FAQ
The key risks include: 1) Financial risk from high debt-to-equity of 3.02x and negative operating margin of -1.58%, which could lead to liquidity concerns if demand weakens; 2) Competitive risk from digital rivals like Carvana, which could pressure market share and pricing; 3) Macro risk from elevated interest rates, which impact the credit-sensitive customer base and could reduce demand; 4) Company-specific risk from reliance on used-vehicle sales (80% of revenue), making it vulnerable to cyclical downturns. The most severe risk is a sustained margin compression that could lead to further losses and a stock decline toward the 52-week low of $30.26.
The 12-month forecast includes three scenarios: bull case (25% probability) with a target range of $75-$96, base case (55% probability) with a target range of $58-$68, and bear case (20% probability) with a target range of $30-$43. The base case is most likely, assuming revenue growth of 10-15% and gradual margin improvement. The key assumption is that CarMax can continue to grow revenue and improve operating margins without a significant deterioration in consumer credit. The wide range reflects high uncertainty.
CarMax appears fairly valued to slightly undervalued on some metrics. Its price-to-book of 1.08x is near the low end of its historical range (0.95x to 4.4x), and price-to-sales of 0.246x is low. However, the trailing PE of 25.70x is elevated relative to history, and the forward PE of 17.78x is reasonable only if earnings meet consensus. The market is pricing in an earnings recovery but remains skeptical about the sustainability of margins. Compared to peers, the valuation is not stretched, but the high leverage and thin margins justify a discount.
CarMax presents a mixed risk/reward profile. The stock trades at $54.92, with analyst average target of $62.62 implying 14% upside, but the bear case could see it fall to $43 or lower. The company has shown strong revenue growth of 19.46% YoY and positive free cash flow, but operating margins remain negative. It could be a good buy for investors who believe in the margin recovery story and can tolerate volatility, but it is not a low-risk investment. The consensus hold rating suggests waiting for clearer signs of sustainable profitability.
CarMax is better suited for a medium-to-long-term investment horizon (at least 1-2 years) given its turnaround nature and cyclicality. The stock has a beta of 1.171 and a maximum drawdown of -50.33%, indicating high volatility that makes short-term trading risky. The company does not pay a dividend, so returns depend entirely on capital appreciation. Earnings visibility is low, with a wide analyst EPS range of $3.21 to $5.49. Investors should be prepared to hold through volatility and monitor quarterly progress on margins and revenue growth.