CarMax
KMX
$61.32
+1.32%
CarMax Inc. is the largest used-vehicle retailer in the United States, operating roughly 260 retail stores and selling, financing, and servicing used and new cars, with used-vehicle sales representing about 80% of fiscal 2026 revenue and wholesale operations contributing roughly 17%. The company is a scaled omnichannel platform in the highly fragmented auto dealership industry, holding an estimated 3.6% share of the US market for vehicles zero to 10 years old, which underscores both its leadership position and the substantial runway for consolidation. The current investor narrative is dominated by a sharp margin and profitability debate: recent headlines highlight a 9.4% drop in gross profit tied to price cuts aimed at driving unit sales, alongside a leadership transition after the company replaced its interim CEO with a hotel-industry executive, which initially spooked investors. More recently, the stock has rebounded on analyst upgrades and resilience in a challenging auto sales environment, but forward guidance concerns and persistent margin pressure keep sentiment divided, with the market weighing whether cost discipline and used-vehicle demand recovery can offset competitive pricing pressure from Carvana and others.…
KMX
CarMax
$61.32
Related headlines
Investment Opinion: Should I buy KMX Today?
We assign a Hold rating on CarMax. The core thesis is that the company is a scaled market leader with a clear path to earnings recovery, but current valuation and negative analyst sentiment limit near-term upside. The consensus target price of $54.85 implies 10.6% downside, and the predominantly neutral-to-bearish ratings from 13 analysts suggest the stock is fairly valued at best after its 56% YTD rally.
Supporting evidence for the Hold includes: 1) Revenue growth of 6.19% year-over-year in the latest quarter, showing stabilization; 2) Trailing free cash flow of $994.3 million, which provides financial flexibility; 3) A low PS ratio of 0.25x, near the bottom of its historical range, indicating deep value on sales; and 4) A forward PE of 20x, which is reasonable if earnings recovery materializes. However, these positives are offset by a negative operating margin of -1.58%, a gross margin of just 9.8%, and an EV/EBITDA of 14.93x that is elevated versus peers.
The biggest risks that could invalidate the Hold thesis are: 1) A failure to restore gross margins above 11%, which would pressure earnings and the valuation multiple; 2) Intensifying competition from Carvana leading to further market share losses; and 3) A macroeconomic downturn that reduces used-car demand and increases credit losses. The rating would upgrade to Buy if gross margins recover above 11% and the forward PE compresses below 18x, or downgrade to Sell if revenue growth turns negative or operating margins remain below -2%. Relative to its own history and peers, KMX appears fairly valued, with the low PS ratio offset by a premium EV/EBITDA and negative earnings quality.
Sign up to view all
KMX 12-Month Price Forecast
CarMax presents a balanced risk/reward profile. The company has demonstrated resilience with a sharp earnings rebound and strong free cash flow, but margin pressures and competitive threats remain significant. The stock's 56% YTD rally has priced in much of the recovery, and analyst targets suggest limited upside. We would upgrade to bullish if gross margins recover above 11% and revenue growth accelerates above 8%, or downgrade to bearish if operating margins remain negative and market share losses continue.
Wall Street consensus
Most Wall Street analysts maintain a constructive view on CarMax's 12-month outlook, with a consensus price target around $54.85 and implied upside of -10.6% versus the current price.
Average Target
$54.85
0 analysts
Implied Upside
-10.6%
vs. current price
Analyst Count
—
covering this stock
Price Range
$33 - $96
Analyst target range
Thirteen analysts cover CarMax, and the consensus recommendation is effectively neutral, with a preponderance of Hold, Neutral, and Equal Weight ratings and a notable bearish tilt from firms like Barclays, JP Morgan, and B of A Securities, which carry Underweight or Underperform ratings. The average price target is $54.85, which implies a downside of approximately -10.6% from the current price of $61.32, indicating that the consensus view is that the stock is overvalued after its recent rally. This bearish consensus target stands in stark contrast to the stock's strong momentum, suggesting that analysts are skeptical of the sustainability of the recovery and see limited upside from current levels.
The target range is exceptionally wide, from a low of $33.00 to a high of $96.00, a spread of nearly 3x that signals very low conviction and high uncertainty about the company's future. The high target of $96 likely assumes a successful margin recovery, accelerating used-vehicle demand, and multiple expansion, while the low target of $33 prices in continued margin compression, competitive share losses, and a challenging consumer credit environment. Notably, the institutional ratings data shows no recent upgrades—most firms reiterated their existing ratings in June 2026, with several maintaining bearish stances—which suggests that the analyst community remains cautious despite the stock's price recovery; the wide dispersion and lack of bullish revisions imply that the market is pricing in a best-case scenario that analysts are not yet willing to endorse.
Bulls vs Bears: KMX Investment Factors
The bull case rests on powerful momentum, a sharp earnings rebound, and deep value on sales metrics, while the bear case is anchored in negative analyst sentiment, severe margin compression, and high leverage. Currently, the bear evidence appears stronger: the consensus target implies 10.6% downside, operating margins are negative, and the stock trades at a premium EV/EBITDA of 14.93x versus the typical 6–10x for auto retailers. The single most important tension is whether CarMax can restore gross margins above 11% through pricing discipline and cost controls without sacrificing unit growth—if margins recover, the stock could re-rate toward the high analyst target of $96; if they remain depressed, the low target of $33 becomes a realistic downside.
Bullish
- Momentum and relative strength leadership: KMX has surged 56.07% year-to-date and 46.56% over six months, outperforming SPY by 43.99 and 31.16 percentage points respectively. The stock is trading at $61.32, just 6.1% below its 52-week high of $65.28, signaling strong institutional accumulation.
- Earnings recovery already underway: The latest quarter delivered EPS of $1.31 and net income of $185.6 million, a dramatic reversal from the prior quarter's net loss of $120.7 million (EPS -$0.77). Revenue grew 6.19% year-over-year to $8.01 billion, indicating demand stabilization.
- Deep value on sales and book metrics: The PS ratio of 0.25x is near the low end of its five-year historical range of 0.80x–2.68x, and the PB ratio of 1.08x is modest. This suggests the market is pricing in a worst-case margin scenario despite improving fundamentals.
- Strong free cash flow generation: Trailing twelve-month free cash flow stands at $994.3 million, providing ample liquidity to fund operations, reduce debt, or invest in growth initiatives. The current ratio of 2.20 further confirms short-term financial health.
Bearish
- Analyst consensus sees downside: The average analyst target price is $54.85, implying a 10.6% decline from the current price of $61.32. Thirteen analysts are predominantly neutral or bearish, with firms like Barclays and JP Morgan carrying Underweight ratings.
- Severe margin compression: Gross margin fell to 9.8% in the May 2026 quarter from 11.84% a year earlier, and the trailing operating margin is negative at -1.58%. Price cuts aimed at driving volume have eroded profitability, with gross profit down 9.4% in a recent quarter.
- Elevated leverage and weak returns: The debt-to-equity ratio of 3.02 and total debt-to-capitalization of 75.3% are high, while ROE of 4.20% and ROA of 1.56% are well below typical retail benchmarks. This limits financial flexibility and increases vulnerability to rising interest rates.
- Extreme target dispersion signals uncertainty: Analyst targets range from $33 to $96, a nearly 3x spread that reflects very low conviction. The lack of recent upgrades despite the stock's rally suggests analysts are not yet convinced of a sustainable turnaround.
KMX Technical Analysis
CarMax is in a powerful recovery uptrend, with the stock up 11.43% over the past year and a striking 56.07% year-to-date, though the 1-year gain masks a volatile path that included a 50.33% maximum drawdown. At a current price of $61.32, the stock sits at roughly 94% of its 52-week range (low of $30.26, high of $65.28), positioning it near the top of its annual band, which signals strong momentum but also raises the risk of overextension and profit-taking. The recovery from the 52-week low represents a more than doubling of the share price, reflecting a dramatic shift in market sentiment from deep pessimism to cautious optimism.
Short-term momentum is clearly positive but decelerating: the stock is up 4.45% over the past month and 19.63% over three months, yet the 1-month gain lags the 3-month pace, suggesting the rally is maturing. The 6-month change of 46.56% and YTD gain of 56.07% confirm that the bulk of the move occurred earlier in the year, and the recent consolidation near $61 could be a pause before continuation or a sign of waning buying pressure. Relative strength versus the S&P 500 is telling: KMX outperformed SPY by 16.59 percentage points over three months and 31.16 points over six months, but it lagged SPY by 16.11 points over the past year, highlighting that the recovery is a recent phenomenon and the stock is still repairing longer-term underperformance.
Key technical levels are well-defined: the 52-week high of $65.28 serves as immediate resistance, while the 52-week low of $30.26 marks the ultimate support zone, with intermediate support likely near the $55-$57 area where the stock consolidated in July and August. A breakout above $65.28 on strong volume would signal a new leg higher and likely draw momentum buyers, while a breakdown below $55 could trigger a retest of the $50 level and undermine the recovery thesis. With a beta of 1.171, KMX is about 17% more volatile than the broader market, meaning position sizing should account for amplified moves in both directions; the short ratio of 6.36 also indicates a meaningful short base that could fuel a squeeze on further upside.
Beta
1.17
1.17x market volatility
Max Drawdown
-50.3%
Largest decline past year
52-Week Range
$30-$65
Price range past year
Annual Return
+0.1%
Cumulative gain past year
| Period | KMX Return | S&P 500 |
|---|---|---|
| 1m | +4.4% | -1.6% |
| 3m | +19.6% | +1.3% |
| 6m | +46.6% | +13.9% |
| 1y | +0.1% | +16.3% |
| ytd | +56.1% | +12.1% |
Bobby - Your AI Investment Partner
Get real-time data, AI-driven personalized investment analysis to make smarter investment decisions
KMX Fundamental Analysis
CarMax's revenue trajectory is showing signs of stabilization after a period of pressure, with the most recent quarter (ended May 31, 2026) delivering $8.01 billion in revenue, up 6.19% year-over-year. However, the multi-quarter trend reveals volatility: revenue fell to $5.95 billion in the February 2026 quarter (down from $6.00 billion a year earlier) and $5.79 billion in the November 2025 quarter (down from $6.22 billion), before rebounding in the May quarter. The used-vehicle segment generated $4.78 billion and wholesale contributed $1.01 billion in the latest period, with the used business remaining the primary growth engine; the sequential recovery suggests demand is stabilizing, but the YoY growth rate of 6.19% is modest for a company with significant operating leverage, implying that unit growth and pricing remain constrained by a competitive used-car market.
Profitability is thin and under pressure, with a net margin of just 0.96% and a gross margin of 10.84%, both of which are low in absolute terms and reflect the highly competitive nature of used-car retailing. The latest quarter showed net income of $185.6 million and EPS of $1.31, a sharp improvement from the prior quarter's net loss of $120.7 million (EPS of -$0.77), but the gross margin of 9.8% in the May quarter was down from 11.84% a year earlier, indicating that price cuts to drive volume are compressing profitability. Operating margin is negative at -1.58% on a trailing basis, and the company's ability to expand margins will depend on balancing unit growth with pricing discipline, a challenge exacerbated by Carvana's aggressive market share push.
CarMax's balance sheet carries meaningful leverage, with a debt-to-equity ratio of 3.02 and total debt-to-capitalization of 75.3%, which is high but typical for an auto retailer that finances its inventory and customer loans. The current ratio of 2.20 provides adequate short-term liquidity, and free cash flow on a trailing twelve-month basis is $994.3 million, though the most recent quarter saw negative free cash flow of -$85.7 million due to working capital swings and capital expenditures of $103.3 million. ROE is low at 4.20% and ROA is just 1.56%, reflecting the capital-intensive nature of the business and thin margins; the company's ability to generate consistent free cash flow will be critical to deleveraging and funding future growth without relying on external financing.
Quarterly Revenue
$8.0B
2026-05
Revenue YoY Growth
+6.2%
YoY Comparison
Gross Margin
9.8%
Latest Quarter
Free Cash Flow
$994305000.0B
Last 12 Months
Revenue & Net Income Trends (2 Years)
Revenue Breakdown
Open an Account, get $2 TSLA now!
Valuation Analysis: Is KMX Overvalued?
Because CarMax is profitable on a trailing basis (net income of $185.6 million in the latest quarter), the PE ratio is the primary valuation metric, and the stock trades at a trailing PE of 25.70x versus a forward PE of 20.00x. The gap between trailing and forward multiples implies the market expects earnings growth of roughly 28% over the next year, which is optimistic given the company's recent margin pressures and the fact that trailing EPS is only $0.04 on a TTM basis (distorted by the prior quarter's loss). The forward PE of 20x is more reflective of normalized earnings power, with analysts estimating average EPS of $3.00 for the coming year, suggesting the market is pricing in a significant earnings recovery.
Relative to the auto dealership industry, CarMax's valuation appears mixed: its PS ratio of 0.25x is exceptionally low, reflecting the high-revenue, low-margin nature of the business, while its PB ratio of 1.08x is modest. The EV/EBITDA of 14.93x is elevated for a traditional auto retailer, where multiples in the 6-10x range are more typical, suggesting the market is assigning a premium for CarMax's scale, digital capabilities, and potential earnings recovery. However, the negative PEG ratio of -0.54 (due to trailing earnings distortions) and the low net margin of 0.96% highlight the risk that the premium is not fully supported by current fundamentals; the stock's valuation is essentially a bet on margin normalization and unit growth.
Historically, CarMax's PE ratio has ranged widely, from a low of 8.59x in the May 2026 quarter to over 70x during periods of depressed earnings, with the current trailing PE of 25.70x sitting in the middle of that range. The PS ratio of 0.25x is near the low end of its historical band (which has ranged from 0.80x to 2.68x over the past five years), suggesting the stock is cheap on a sales basis relative to its own history. This dichotomy—low PS but mid-range PE—reflects the market's expectation that margins will recover; if they do not, the stock could be vulnerable to a re-rating lower, but if margin expansion materializes, the current valuation could prove attractive.
PE
25.7x
Latest Quarter
vs. Historical
Mid-Range
5-Year PE Range 9x~39x
vs. Industry Avg
N/A
Industry PE ~N/A*
EV/EBITDA
14.9x
Enterprise Value Multiple
Investment Risk Disclosure
CarMax faces significant financial and operational risks. The debt-to-equity ratio of 3.02 and total debt-to-capitalization of 75.3% indicate a heavily leveraged balance sheet, which is typical for auto retailers but leaves little room for error if cash flows deteriorate. Gross margin has compressed to 9.8% in the latest quarter from 11.84% a year earlier, and the trailing operating margin is negative at -1.58%, highlighting the difficulty of maintaining profitability amid price cuts. Additionally, the most recent quarter saw negative free cash flow of -$85.7 million, driven by working capital swings and $103.3 million in capital expenditures, which could strain liquidity if sustained.
Market and competitive risks are equally concerning. The stock trades at an EV/EBITDA of 14.93x, well above the 6–10x range typical for auto dealerships, leaving it vulnerable to multiple compression if earnings disappoint. Carvana's aggressive expansion and high interest rates affecting credit-sensitive consumers pose direct threats to CarMax's market share and unit economics. With a beta of 1.171, KMX is 17% more volatile than the broader market, meaning any macro-driven selloff could hit the stock disproportionately. Recent news of a 9.4% drop in gross profit due to price cuts underscores the intense competitive pressure.
In a worst-case scenario, continued margin erosion, market share losses to Carvana, and a consumer credit downturn could drive the stock toward its 52-week low of $30.26 or the analyst low target of $33.00. From the current price of $61.32, that represents a potential loss of 46% to 51%. Such a scenario would likely involve a recession, rising unemployment, and further price wars, compressing both earnings and the valuation multiple. The maximum drawdown over the past year was already 50.33%, demonstrating that such a decline is not unprecedented.
FAQ
The most severe risk is margin compression: gross margin fell to 9.8% in the latest quarter from 11.84% a year earlier, and operating margin is negative at -1.58%. Financial risk is high with a debt-to-equity ratio of 3.02 and total debt-to-capitalization of 75.3%, leaving little room for error. Competitive risk from Carvana's aggressive expansion could lead to further market share losses and price wars. Macro risk is amplified by a beta of 1.171, meaning KMX is 17% more volatile than the market, and high interest rates could dampen used-car demand. These risks are ranked from most to least severe: margin, financial, competitive, macro.
Our 12-month forecast has three scenarios: a bull case with 25% probability targeting $80–$96, a base case with 50% probability targeting $50–$60, and a bear case with 25% probability targeting $30–$40. The base case is most likely, assuming revenue growth of 5-7% and gross margins stabilizing around 10-10.5%, with EPS near the analyst average of $3.00. The key assumption is that used-vehicle demand remains stable and competitive pressures do not intensify. The wide target range reflects high uncertainty, with analyst targets spanning $33 to $96.
KMX appears fairly valued to slightly overvalued on earnings-based metrics but undervalued on sales. The trailing PE of 25.70x and forward PE of 20x are mid-range historically, while the EV/EBITDA of 14.93x is elevated versus the 6-10x typical for auto retailers. The PS ratio of 0.25x is near the low end of its five-year range of 0.80x–2.68x, suggesting the market is pricing in depressed margins. The market expects earnings growth of roughly 28% over the next year, which is optimistic given recent margin pressures. If margin recovery materializes, the stock could be undervalued; if not, it is overvalued.
From a risk/reward perspective, KMX is a Hold rather than a strong buy. The stock has rallied 56% YTD and trades at $61.32, just 6% below its 52-week high, while the analyst average target of $54.85 implies 10.6% downside. The biggest downside risk is a return to the 52-week low of $30.26, representing a 51% loss, if margin pressures persist. However, for investors with a long-term horizon and tolerance for volatility, the potential earnings recovery and low PS ratio of 0.25x could offer value. It is a good buy only if gross margins show sustained recovery above 11% and revenue growth accelerates.
KMX is more suitable for medium-to-long-term investment (at least 1-2 years) given its turnaround nature and high volatility. The stock has a beta of 1.171 and a maximum drawdown of 50.33% over the past year, making it risky for short-term trading. It pays no dividend (payout ratio 0%), so returns depend entirely on capital appreciation. Earnings visibility is low due to margin uncertainty and competitive dynamics. A minimum holding period of 18-24 months is suggested to allow for potential margin recovery and market share stabilization. Short-term traders could exploit momentum, but should use tight stop-losses given the 6.36 short ratio and potential for sharp reversals.