Commercial Metals Company
CMC
$64.98
-0.60%
Commercial Metals Company is a vertically integrated manufacturer and recycler of steel and metal products, producing reinforcing bar, merchant bar, wire rod, steel fence posts, and downstream construction solutions such as concrete pipes, precast products, and ground stabilization systems, serving infrastructure, commercial, and residential construction markets across the United States, Europe, and Asia. CMC is best understood as a regional steel mini-mill operator with a distinctive scrap-recycling backbone and a growing downstream fabrication footprint, positioning it as a domestically focused, low-cost producer rather than a global commodity steel player. The current investor narrative centers on the tension between a strong recent operating rebound — highlighted by Q4 fiscal 2026 earnings and revenue beats reported in mid-October — and persistent share price underperformance, with the stock down roughly 9.5% year-to-date despite a 22.9% year-over-year revenue surge in the latest quarter. Debate now hinges on whether the recent margin recovery and construction-demand tailwinds can be sustained into fiscal 2027, or whether steel pricing pressure and a soft non-residential construction backdrop will cap the earnings recovery, a question amplified by a wide dispersion in analyst price targets.…
CMC
Commercial Metals Company
$64.98
Related headlines
Investment Opinion: Should I buy CMC Today?
Rating: Buy. The core thesis is that CMC is a vertically integrated, recycling-backed steel producer trading at a deep cyclical discount (9.51x forward earnings) while earnings are inflecting—Q3 revenue grew 22.9% YoY and net income more than doubled—and the analyst consensus of 'buy' with an average target of $79.27 implies 22.0% upside. Even the lowest target of $70.00 is 7.7% above the current price, indicating the sell-side views the recent weakness as overdone.
Supporting evidence is broad: the forward PE of 9.51x versus trailing 11.40x implies 17% EPS growth to $6.15, the PEG ratio of 0.017 reflects the sharp earnings rebound, and price-to-book of 1.59x sits near the 1.54x–1.65x levels that have historically marked cyclical troughs. Gross margin of 18.33% is up ~350 basis points YoY, operating margin of 9.09% has room to recover toward the 11.4–15.8% range of fiscal 2022–2023, and free cash flow TTM of $405.0 million provides a 5.4% FCF yield. The 0.80x P/S and 8.07x EV/EBITDA are undemanding for a company with a differentiated downstream mix.
The biggest risks are a sustained construction slowdown that caps margin recovery, the elevated debt load (debt/equity 0.72) following the $2.5 billion acquisition, and the stock's high beta (1.532) amplifying macro-driven drawdowns. The rating would upgrade to a stronger Buy if operating margins sustainably exceed 11% or if the stock breaks above the $72–76 resistance zone; it would downgrade to Hold if revenue growth decelerates below 10% or if gross margins fall back below 16%. On balance, CMC appears undervalued relative to its own history and peers, with the market pricing in a mid-cycle earnings outlook that the recent quarter suggests may prove conservative.
Sign up to view all
CMC 12-Month Price Forecast
The forward view is constructive: CMC's earnings inflection is real, valuation is undemanding at 9.51x forward earnings, and the analyst consensus is uniformly above the current price, suggesting the recent underperformance is an overreaction. The main uncertainty is durability—operating margin at 9.09% is still well below historical peaks, and the post-acquisition leverage (debt/equity 0.72) limits flexibility if construction demand softens. I would upgrade to high confidence if Q4 results confirm operating margin above 10% and fiscal 2027 guidance supports the $6.15 EPS estimate; I would downgrade to neutral if gross margin falls below 16% or if revenue growth decelerates below 10%, signaling the recovery has stalled.
Wall Street consensus
Most Wall Street analysts maintain a constructive view on Commercial Metals Company's 12-month outlook, with a consensus price target around $79.27 and implied upside of +22.0% versus the current price.
Average Target
$79.27
0 analysts
Implied Upside
+22.0%
vs. current price
Analyst Count
—
covering this stock
Price Range
$70 - $88
Analyst target range
Coverage is robust, with 11 analysts and a consensus recommendation of "buy" (mean rating of 1.92 on a 1–5 scale where lower is more bullish). The average target price of $79.27 implies roughly 22.0% upside from the current $64.98, and notably even the lowest target of $70.00 sits about 7.7% above the current price — a rare configuration where no analyst sees downside, suggesting the sell-side views the recent weakness as an overreaction. The consensus leans clearly bullish, supported by the forward EPS estimate of $6.15 and revenue estimate of $10.68 billion, which underpin the case that earnings are inflecting.
The target range spans $70.00 to $88.00, a spread of about 25.7% around the average, which signals moderate-to-high uncertainty rather than tight conviction. The high target of $88.00 (35.4% upside) likely assumes multiple expansion back toward historical mid-cycle levels alongside sustained margin recovery and construction-demand acceleration, while the low target of $70.00 (7.7% upside) prices in margin compression and a softer non-residential construction cycle. Institutional ratings show a mixed but stabilizing pattern: UBS upgraded to Buy from Neutral in May 2026, Morgan Stanley and JP Morgan maintain Overweight, and B of A and Citigroup reiterate Buy, but Wells Fargo downgraded to Equal Weight from Overweight in June 2026 and BMO remains at Market Perform — a split that mirrors the wide target dispersion and suggests the Street is divided on the durability of the earnings rebound despite the bullish average.
Bulls vs Bears: CMC Investment Factors
The bull case rests on a genuine earnings inflection—22.9% revenue growth, net income more than doubling YoY, and a forward PE of 9.51x that prices in recovery—supported by a unanimous analyst consensus that even the lowest target is above the current price. The bear case counters that the market has consistently punished CMC despite beats (YTD -9.49% vs. SPY +11.93%), leverage has risen materially post-acquisition, and the cyclical earnings history includes a recent quarterly loss. On balance, the bull evidence is currently stronger: the fundamental trajectory is improving, valuation is undemanding, and analyst targets imply 22% upside. The single most important tension is whether the Q3 margin recovery (operating margin 9.38%) can be sustained and built upon toward the 11–15% historical range—if it can, the stock is materially undervalued; if steel pricing and construction demand soften, the forward earnings estimate of $6.15 will prove too optimistic and the discount is deserved.
Bullish
- Earnings inflection with 22.9% revenue growth: Q3 fiscal 2026 revenue surged 22.9% YoY to $2.483 billion from $2.020 billion, with a sharp sequential acceleration from $2.132 billion in Q2. Net income more than doubled to $173.0 million (EPS $1.56) from $83.1 million a year ago, and operating margin expanded to 9.38% from 7.26% sequentially.
- Deep value multiple with 22% analyst upside: At 11.40x trailing and 9.51x forward earnings, CMC trades at a steep discount to its own historical range (PE up to 55x) and typical steel peers. The consensus average target of $79.27 implies 22.0% upside, and even the lowest target of $70.00 sits 7.7% above the current $64.98 price.
- Margin recovery has further headroom: Gross margin of 18.33% is up roughly 350 basis points YoY from 14.85%, but operating margin of 9.09% remains well below the 11.4–15.8% range posted in fiscal 2022–2023. If construction demand holds, normalization toward those levels would drive meaningful EPS upside beyond the $6.15 consensus.
- Recycling-backed cost advantage and downstream mix: CMC's vertically integrated, scrap-recycling model and growing downstream fabrication footprint (Downstream Products at $646 million and Steel Products at $951 million in Q3) differentiate it from commodity steel producers. This mix supports a 1.59x P/B and 0.80x P/S that look modest relative to the 18.6% gross margin.
Bearish
- Persistent relative underperformance despite beats: CMC is down 9.49% YTD versus the S&P 500's +11.93%, a -21.4% relative strength gap, and has underperformed over 1, 3, and 6 months (-2.50, -4.84, -9.28 relative strength). The market is clearly discounting earnings beats, suggesting skepticism about durability.
- Leverage jumped after $2.5 billion acquisition: Debt-to-equity has risen to 0.72 from ~0.28–0.33 in fiscal 2024–2025, and cash fell from $3.03 billion to $504 million after a $2.516 billion acquisition outflow. Interest expense rose to $40.2 million in Q3 from $10.9 million a year ago, a direct drag on earnings.
- Earnings volatility and prior-year loss: CMC posted a net loss of -$175.7 million (EPS -$1.54) in Q1 fiscal 2025, illustrating the cyclicality of its earnings base. The trailing PE of 11.40x is calculated on a depressed TTM EPS of ~$5.70, and the forward discount to 9.51x assumes a recovery that may not materialize if steel pricing weakens.
- High beta amplifies drawdown risk: With a beta of 1.532, CMC is roughly 53% more volatile than the market, and its maximum drawdown of -29.96% over the past year demonstrates the severity of downside moves. In a risk-off or recessionary scenario, the stock could retest its 52-week low of $55.70, a further 14.3% decline.
CMC Technical Analysis
CMC is in a range-bound consolidation with a modestly positive longer-term tilt, having gained 17.4% over the trailing twelve months while sitting just 23.4% above its 52-week low of $55.70 and 23.4% below its 52-week high of $84.87 — placing the current $64.98 price at roughly 76.6% of its 52-week range. That positioning signals neither momentum-driven overextension nor a falling-knife setup; instead, the stock has surrendered most of its mid-year gains and is now trading in the lower-middle of its annual band, consistent with a market that has de-rated the shares despite improving fundamentals. The 1-year gain of 17.4% actually edges out the S&P 500's 15.5% advance (relative strength of +1.87), but the path has been volatile, with a maximum drawdown of -29.96% underscoring how sharply the stock has corrected from its highs.
Short-term momentum is clearly negative and diverging from the longer-term uptrend: the stock is down 1.28% over the past month, 2.15% over three months, and 1.80% over six months, while the S&P 500 gained 1.22%, 2.69%, and 7.48% over the same windows, producing relative strength readings of -2.50, -4.84, and -9.28 respectively. This persistent underperformance against a rising market is a cautionary divergence — it suggests the market is discounting the earnings beats rather than rewarding them, and the year-to-date decline of 9.49% versus the SPY's +11.93% (a -21.4% relative strength gap) is the starkest evidence of decelerating momentum. The stock's recent bounce from the late-September low near $62.05 to $64.98 is constructive but insufficient to reverse the intermediate downtrend, and with a short ratio of 5.83 days-to-cover, there is meaningful bearish positioning that could fuel a squeeze on any positive catalyst.
Key technical levels are well defined: support sits at the 52-week low of $55.70, with a nearer-term floor around the $62 area tested in late September, while resistance is anchored at the 52-week high of $84.87, with intermediate supply likely near the $72–76 zone where the stock repeatedly failed in August. A breakout above $76 would signal a trend reversal and likely open a path toward the highs, whereas a breakdown below $62 would confirm the downtrend and expose the $55.70 low. With a beta of 1.532, CMC is roughly 53% more volatile than the market, meaning position sizing should account for amplified drawdowns — the -29.96% max drawdown is a direct manifestation of this high-beta profile, and risk management should assume daily swings roughly 1.5x the index.
Beta
1.53
1.53x market volatility
Max Drawdown
-30.0%
Largest decline past year
52-Week Range
$56-$85
Price range past year
Annual Return
+17.4%
Cumulative gain past year
| Period | CMC Return | S&P 500 |
|---|---|---|
| 1m | -1.3% | +0.2% |
| 3m | -2.2% | +2.9% |
| 6m | -1.8% | +8.4% |
| 1y | +17.4% | +14.9% |
| ytd | -9.5% | +11.9% |
Bobby - Your AI Investment Partner
Get real-time data, AI-driven personalized investment analysis to make smarter investment decisions
CMC Fundamental Analysis
CMC's revenue trajectory has inflected sharply upward: the most recent quarter (ended May 31, 2026) delivered $2.483 billion in revenue, up 22.9% year-over-year from $2.020 billion, and up sequentially from $2.132 billion in Q2 and $2.120 billion in Q1. The multi-quarter trend shows clear acceleration — Q1 fiscal 2026 revenue of $2.120 billion and Q2's $2.132 billion were roughly flat, before Q3's 16.5% sequential jump to $2.483 billion, suggesting a genuine demand or pricing inflection rather than steady-state growth. Within the segment mix, Steel Products at $951 million and Downstream Products at $646 million are the largest contributors, with Raw Material Products at $461 million, indicating the core mill and fabrication businesses are driving the rebound; the 22.9% growth rate, if sustained, would support the consensus revenue estimate of roughly $10.68 billion for the forward period.
Profitability has recovered materially from the prior-year trough: Q3 fiscal 2026 net income reached $173.0 million (EPS of $1.56) on a 6.97% net margin and 18.33% gross margin, a dramatic improvement from the year-ago quarter's $83.1 million net income (4.12% net margin, 14.85% gross margin). The sequential progression is equally telling — net income rose from $93.0 million in Q2 (4.36% margin) to $173.0 million in Q3, while operating margin expanded from 7.26% to 9.38% and EBITDA margin from 11.88% to 13.55%. Gross margin has been relatively stable in the 18.2–19.2% band over the last three quarters but is up roughly 350 basis points year-over-year, and the 9.09% operating margin and 6.98% net margin, while healthy for a steel producer, remain below the 11.4–15.8% operating margins CMC posted in fiscal 2022–2023, implying further recovery headroom if construction demand holds.
The balance sheet is solid but has been reshaped by a major acquisition: the Q2 fiscal 2026 cash flow statement shows a $2.516 billion acquisition outflow that drew cash down from $3.03 billion to $504 million, and debt-to-equity now stands at 0.72 with a current ratio of 2.34 — still comfortable liquidity, but leverage has risen meaningfully from the ~0.28–0.33 debt/equity levels seen through fiscal 2024–2025. Free cash flow TTM is $405.0 million, with quarterly FCF of $76.4 million in Q3 against $156.1 million of capex, and operating cash flow of $232.6 million; ROE of 13.96% and ROA of 6.24% are respectable but below the 2022–2023 peak levels. The company funds growth internally and pays a modest dividend (1.13% yield, 12.8% payout ratio), but the acquisition-driven debt increase and elevated capex mean FCF conversion bears watching — the FCF yield of roughly 5.4% on the $7.48 billion market cap is adequate but not generous for a cyclical.
Quarterly Revenue
$2.5B
2026-05
Revenue YoY Growth
+22.9%
YoY Comparison
Gross Margin
18.3%
Latest Quarter
Free Cash Flow
$405038000.0B
Last 12 Months
Revenue & Net Income Trends (2 Years)
Revenue Breakdown
Open an Account, get $2 TSLA now!
Valuation Analysis: Is CMC Overvalued?
Because CMC is solidly profitable (Q3 net income of $173.0 million, positive TTM earnings), the PE ratio is the appropriate primary metric. The stock trades at 11.40x trailing earnings but only 9.51x forward earnings, and the gap implies the market expects meaningful EPS growth — consistent with the consensus forward EPS estimate of $6.15 versus the current TTM EPS of roughly $5.70. That forward discount of about 17% signals the market is pricing in earnings normalization from the depressed prior-year base rather than multiple expansion, and the PEG ratio of 0.017 (reflecting the sharp earnings rebound) makes the stock look inexpensive on a growth-adjusted basis.
Against the broader steel and basic materials sector, CMC screens as a value play: its 11.40x trailing PE and 9.51x forward PE are well below the multiples typically commanded by integrated steel peers, and its 0.80x price-to-sales and 1.59x price-to-book are modest for a company with 18.6% gross margins and a vertically integrated, recycling-backed cost structure. The EV/EBITDA of 8.07x and EV/Sales of 1.05x are similarly undemanding, suggesting the market is applying a cyclical discount rather than paying for the downstream fabrication mix or the acquisition's strategic value. The discount appears at least partly justified by the leverage increase (debt/equity of 0.72) and the volatile earnings history, but it also leaves room for re-rating if margins normalize toward historical levels.
On its own history, CMC's valuation is near the middle-to-lower end of its multi-year band: the trailing PE of 11.40x compares with 12.14x in the prior quarter, 10.01x a year ago, and a range spanning roughly 3.8x–55x over the past four years, while the price-to-book of 1.59x sits between the 1.28x low of mid-2025 and the 1.85x seen earlier in 2026. The current 1.59x P/B is close to the 1.54x–1.65x levels that have marked prior cyclical troughs, implying the market is pricing in a cautious, mid-cycle earnings outlook rather than optimism. Historically, CMC has traded at 1.2x–1.8x book through downturns and above 2x only during peak steel-margin periods, so the present level suggests limited downside from multiple compression but also limited near-term re-rating absent a sustained margin recovery.
PE
11.4x
Latest Quarter
vs. Historical
Mid-Range
5-Year PE Range 3x~22x
vs. Industry Avg
N/A
Industry PE ~N/A*
EV/EBITDA
8.1x
Enterprise Value Multiple
Investment Risk Disclosure
Financial and operational risks center on the balance-sheet transformation following the $2.516 billion acquisition in Q2 fiscal 2026, which drew cash from $3.03 billion to $504 million and lifted debt-to-equity to 0.72 from ~0.28–0.33 in fiscal 2024–2025. Interest expense jumped to $40.2 million in Q3 from $10.9 million a year earlier, directly compressing net income, while quarterly free cash flow of $76.4 million against $156.1 million of capex leaves limited cushion if margins slip. Revenue concentration in cyclical construction end-markets is another vulnerability: Steel Products ($951 million) and Downstream Products ($646 million) together represent roughly 64% of Q3 revenue, tying results tightly to non-residential construction activity. Finally, the earnings base is volatile—Q1 fiscal 2025 produced a net loss of -$175.7 million—so the forward EPS estimate of $6.15 depends on continued recovery that is not yet proven across a full cycle.
Market and competitive risks include valuation compression if the cyclical discount persists: at 11.40x trailing and 9.51x forward earnings, CMC is already cheap, but a re-rating requires sustained margin recovery that peers may not deliver either. The stock's beta of 1.532 means it is roughly 53% more volatile than the market, so any macro deterioration—particularly a rise in rates that slows construction—would hit CMC disproportionately. Competitive pressure from larger, lower-cost steel producers and import competition could cap pricing power, while the wide analyst target dispersion ($70–$88) and split ratings (Wells Fargo downgrade to Equal Weight, BMO at Market Perform) signal that the Street is not convinced the rebound is durable. Recent news highlighting Q4 beats alongside a Hold rating and underperformance underscores that positive results are not translating into market confidence.
In a worst-case scenario, a renewed downturn in non-residential construction combined with steel price weakness would compress margins back toward the prior-year trough (gross margin 14.85%, net margin 4.12%), causing forward EPS estimates to be cut sharply and the stock to retest its 52-week low of $55.70—a 14.3% decline from the current $64.98. A more severe outcome, such as a recession that pushes the stock toward its maximum drawdown of -29.96%, would imply a price near $45.50, a loss of roughly 30% from current levels. The combination of high beta, elevated leverage, and cyclical end-market exposure makes this downside scenario plausible if macro conditions deteriorate, and the 5.83-day short ratio suggests bearish positioning that could accelerate a selloff.
FAQ
The most severe risk is cyclical demand deterioration: a slowdown in non-residential construction would compress margins back toward the prior-year trough (gross margin 14.85%, net margin 4.12%) and could push the stock toward its 52-week low of $55.70, a 14.3% decline. Second is balance-sheet risk from the $2.5 billion acquisition, which lifted debt/equity to 0.72 and interest expense to $40.2 million per quarter, limiting flexibility if earnings disappoint. Third is market risk from the high beta of 1.532, which amplifies drawdowns—the maximum drawdown of -29.96% over the past year illustrates this. Fourth is earnings volatility, evidenced by the -$175.7 million net loss in Q1 fiscal 2025, which shows the company is not immune to sharp downturns. These risks are ranked in that order of severity.
The 12-month forecast has three scenarios: a base case (50% probability) targeting $70.00–$79.27, aligned with the analyst average of $79.27, assuming gradual margin recovery and EPS near the $6.15 consensus; a bull case (30% probability) targeting $84.87–$88.00, driven by operating margins returning to 11–15% and multiple expansion; and a bear case (20% probability) targeting $55.70–$70.00, reflecting a construction slowdown and margin compression. The base case is most likely, with the key assumption that gross margin holds in the 18–19% band and forward EPS of $6.15 is achieved within a few percent. The wide target range ($70–$88) reflects genuine uncertainty about the durability of the recovery.
CMC appears undervalued on both absolute and relative bases. Its trailing PE of 11.40x and forward PE of 9.51x are well below the multiples typically commanded by steel peers and far below its own four-year range of roughly 3.8x–55x. The price-to-book of 1.59x sits near the 1.54x–1.65x levels that have historically marked cyclical troughs, and the 0.80x price-to-sales and 8.07x EV/EBITDA are undemanding for a company with 18.6% gross margins. The market appears to be pricing in a cautious mid-cycle earnings outlook rather than optimism, implying that if the earnings recovery continues, there is room for multiple expansion toward the 12–13x forward range and a re-rating toward the $79–88 area.
From a risk/reward perspective, CMC offers a favorable setup: the stock trades at 9.51x forward earnings with a 22.0% upside to the analyst average target of $79.27, and even the lowest target of $70.00 is 7.7% above the current $64.98 price. The biggest downside risk is a retest of the 52-week low of $55.70, a 14.3% decline, which is less than the potential upside, creating an asymmetric payoff. However, the stock's high beta of 1.532 and the post-acquisition debt load (debt/equity 0.72) mean it is not suitable for risk-averse investors. It is a good buy for value-oriented investors with a 12–18 month horizon who believe the construction cycle will hold and margin recovery will continue; it is less attractive for short-term traders given the persistent negative momentum (YTD -9.49%).
CMC is better suited for medium-to-long-term investment (minimum 12–18 months) than short-term trading. The stock is in a cyclical recovery with earnings inflecting, but the negative short-term momentum (down 1.28% over one month, 2.15% over three months) and high beta of 1.532 make near-term price action unpredictable. The dividend yield of 1.13% is modest and not a reason to hold, but the valuation at 9.51x forward earnings and 1.59x book provides a margin of safety that should reward patient investors as margins normalize. A suggested minimum holding period of 12–18 months allows time for the construction cycle to play out and for the post-acquisition leverage to be reduced, with a target range of $70–$88 depending on the scenario.