Dollar Tree
DLTR
$112.16
-1.98%
Dollar Tree Inc. operates approximately 9,000 small-box discount stores across the United States and Canada, selling a mix of consumables (roughly 49% of sales), variety merchandise (45%), and seasonal goods (6%), with about 85% of items priced under $2 and private-label products accounting for nearly one-third of sales. As one of the largest pure-play discount retailers in North America, the company occupies a distinct position in the consumer defensive sector, competing with Dollar General, Five Below, and mass merchants on a value-per-item basis rather than assortment breadth. The current investor narrative centers on a multi-year turnaround: management has pivoted from the fixed $1 price point to a multi-price strategy, exited the underperforming Family Dollar banner, and is now reinvesting tariff refunds into pricing and store expansion while raising 2026 earnings guidance. Debate among investors hinges on whether gross-margin recovery and aggressive share buybacks can offset soft foot traffic and tariff-driven cost uncertainty, with recent news highlighting both strong earnings beats and caution around store-expansion execution.…
DLTR
Dollar Tree
$112.16
Related headlines
Investment Opinion: Should I buy DLTR Today?
Rating: Hold. The synthesized view is that DLTR is a credible but unproven turnaround trading at a discount, and the risk/reward is balanced rather than compelling at $114.07. The 25-analyst consensus recommendation of 'hold' (mean 2.54) and average target of $136.40 imply 19.6% upside, but the wide $98–$170 range and recent downgrades (Freedom Broker to Hold, BNP Paribas at Underperform) show that upside is contingent on execution that has not yet been demonstrated.
Supporting evidence for the Hold: the forward PE of 14.42x is a 24% discount to the 18.91x trailing multiple and well below the S&P 500's low-20s, while the 1.25x PS ratio is near the low end of DLTR's multi-year range. Gross margin has expanded from 34.43% in Q2 FY2025 to 36.87% in Q1 FY2026, revenue grew 7.24% year-over-year to $4.976 billion, and trailing free cash flow of $1.558 billion comfortably funds the $585.8 million quarterly buyback. ROE of 34.16% and a 6.98% net margin confirm the earnings base is clean after the Family Dollar impairment, and the $136.40 average target offers 19.6% upside if margins hold.
Risks that could invalidate the thesis: first, debt-to-equity of 1.879x and a 1.067 current ratio leave little cushion if FCF compresses; second, the stock's 13.70% one-month decline and 14.39-point underperformance versus SPY suggest momentum could force further de-rating toward the $98 low target; third, tariff-refund reinvestment is a one-time lever, and store-expansion execution remains unproven. This Hold would upgrade to Buy if gross margin holds above 36% for two consecutive quarters and foot traffic stabilizes, or downgrade to Sell if revenue growth decelerates below 5% or the stock breaks below the $112 support shelf. On balance, DLTR is fairly valued to modestly undervalued relative to its own history and peers, but not cheap enough to compensate for the execution and momentum risks.
Sign up to view all
DLTR 12-Month Price Forecast
DLTR presents a genuinely mixed picture: the fundamental turnaround is real, with gross margin up 245 basis points year-over-year, $1.558 billion in trailing free cash flow, and a 14.42x forward PE that is cheap versus both its own history and the market. However, the stock has lost 13.70% in a month, trails SPY by 23.78 points year-to-date, and sits only 51.9% through its 52-week range, while analyst consensus remains a lukewarm 'hold' with a 53%-wide target spread. The base case (50% probability) targets $125–$136.40, implying 10–20% upside if margins hold and buybacks continue, but the bear case (25%) at $84.71–$98 reflects real downside if traffic or tariffs deteriorate. I would upgrade to bullish if Q3 FY2026 shows gross margin above 37% with positive traffic and a guidance raise, and downgrade to bearish if the stock breaks below $112 or revenue growth falls below 5%.
Wall Street consensus
Most Wall Street analysts maintain a constructive view on Dollar Tree's 12-month outlook, with a consensus price target around $136.80 and implied upside of +22.0% versus the current price.
Average Target
$136.80
0 analysts
Implied Upside
+22.0%
vs. current price
Analyst Count
—
covering this stock
Price Range
$98 - $170
Analyst target range
Coverage is robust with 25 analysts, but sentiment is decidedly mixed: the consensus recommendation is "hold" with a recommendation mean of 2.54 (where 1 is strong buy and 5 is strong sell), and the average price target of $136.40 implies roughly 19.6% upside from the current price of $114.07. The distribution skews cautious — recent actions include Raymond James upgrading to Outperform from Market Perform and Goldman Sachs raising to Neutral from Sell, offset by BNP Paribas maintaining Underperform and Freedom Broker downgrading to Hold from Buy — indicating analysts are warming to the turnaround but not yet willing to endorse it unanimously. The consensus is best characterized as neutral-to-constructive, with the average target reflecting upside that the current price has yet to discount.
The target range is wide, from a low of $98.00 (about 14.1% below the current price) to a high of $170.00 (roughly 49.0% above), a spread of $72 or about 53% of the current price — signaling high uncertainty and low conviction rather than a tight consensus. The high target of $170 likely assumes successful multi-price expansion, sustained gross-margin recovery toward 40%, continued buyback-driven EPS accretion, and multiple re-rating toward 20x forward earnings; the low target of $98 prices in margin compression from tariffs, weakening discretionary traffic, and store-expansion missteps. The upgrade/downgrade pattern over the past four months is net positive (two upgrades versus one downgrade), and with estimated EPS of $8.39 and revenue of $25.03 billion underpinning targets, the key swing factor is whether management's raised 2026 guidance and tariff-refund reinvestment translate into durable earnings power — a wide target spread that argues for position sizing discipline and event-driven entry points around quarterly prints.
Bulls vs Bears: DLTR Investment Factors
The bear case currently has stronger near-term evidence: DLTR has lost 13.70% in a month, trails SPY by 14.39 points over that period, and sits mid-range at $114.07 between a $84.71 low and $142.40 high, with analyst consensus stuck at 'hold' (2.54 mean). The bull case rests on genuinely improving fundamentals — gross margin up from 34.43% to 36.87% year-over-year, $1.558 billion in trailing free cash flow, and a 14.42x forward PE — but these are being overwhelmed by deteriorating price momentum and execution skepticism. The single most important tension is whether the tariff-refund-funded reinvestment and multi-price rollout can convert into durable foot-traffic and earnings growth before the next quarterly print; if Q3 shows margin expansion continuing alongside positive traffic, the stock likely re-rates toward the $136.40 average target, but if traffic stays soft, the $98 low target comes into play.
Bullish
- Gross margin recovery is real and sustained: Gross margin expanded from 34.43% in Q2 FY2025 to 35.89% in Q3 FY2025, 39.17% in Q4 FY2025, and 36.87% in Q1 FY2026, driven by multi-price mix, private label (nearly one-third of sales), and lower shrink. This is a structural mix shift, not a one-quarter blip, and it directly lifts operating leverage.
- Forward PE of 14.4x is undemanding: DLTR trades at 14.42x forward earnings versus 18.91x trailing, a 24% discount that implies the market expects EPS to grow from the current run-rate toward the $8.39 consensus estimate. The 1.25x PS ratio and 12.92x EV/EBITDA are also modest for a defensive retailer with 36.4% gross margins.
- Aggressive buybacks shrink the share count: The company repurchased $585.8 million of stock in Q1 FY2026 alone and repaid $500 million of debt, reducing diluted shares from 215.3 million in Q4 FY2024 to 197.4 million in Q1 FY2026. With a 0% dividend, all capital return flows through buybacks, mechanically boosting EPS even on flat net income.
- Analyst average target implies 19.6% upside: The 25-analyst consensus average target of $136.40 sits 19.6% above the $114.07 current price, with the high target of $170 implying 49% upside. Recent actions skew positive, including Raymond James upgrading to Outperform and Goldman Sachs raising to Neutral from Sell.
Bearish
- Momentum has broken down sharply: DLTR is down 13.70% over the past month and 7.91% over three months, versus a 21.31% one-year gain, and trails SPY by 14.39 percentage points over one month. The September slide from $131.42 to $114.07 on elevated volume of about 2.0 million shares looks like distribution, not orderly profit-taking.
- Balance sheet leverage is elevated: Debt-to-equity of 1.879x, a thin current ratio of 1.067, and cash flow to debt of only 0.085 indicate meaningful leverage relative to internally generated cash. The $500 million debt repayment in Q1 FY2026 consumed cash that could otherwise buffer a downturn.
- Analyst consensus is only 'hold' with wide dispersion: The recommendation mean of 2.54 (where 1 is strong buy) reflects low conviction, and the target range of $98 to $170 spans 53% of the current price. BNP Paribas maintains Underperform and Freedom Broker downgraded to Hold from Buy, showing the bull case is not universally accepted.
- Revenue growth is mature, not accelerating: Q1 FY2026 revenue grew 7.24% year-over-year to $4.976 billion, but full-year estimated revenue of $25.03 billion implies low-to-mid single-digit expansion. With the Family Dollar divestiture complete, growth now depends entirely on the core banner's multi-price rollout and new-store openings.
DLTR Technical Analysis
DLTR is in a choppy, range-bound recovery rather than a clean trend: the stock is up 21.31% over the past year but sits at $114.07, only about 51.9% of the way through its 52-week range of $84.71 to $142.40, and down 10.67% year-to-date. That positioning — positive on a 12-month basis but mid-range and negative YTD — suggests the market has repriced the turnaround higher off the lows but has not yet validated a breakout to new highs, leaving the stock vulnerable to mean-reversion pressure. The 52-week low of $84.71 is roughly 25.7% below the current price, while the 52-week high of $142.40 implies about 24.8% upside, so the stock is nearly equidistant from both extremes, a classic consolidation signature.
Recent momentum has deteriorated sharply and diverges from the longer-term uptrend: DLTR is down 13.70% over the past month and 7.91% over three months, versus a 1-year gain of 21.31%, meaning the intermediate trend has rolled over even as the annual trend remains positive. Relative strength confirms the weakness — the stock trails SPY by 14.39 percentage points over one month and 13.72 points over three months, and by a striking 23.78 points year-to-date, indicating persistent underperformance versus the broad market. The September slide from $131.42 on September 4 to $114.07 on September 25 (a roughly 13% drawdown in three weeks) on elevated volume of about 2.0 million shares points to distribution rather than orderly profit-taking, and with no RSI provided, the magnitude and speed of the decline suggest oversold conditions may be developing but are not yet confirmed by a reversal signal.
Key technical levels are well defined: support sits at the 52-week low of $84.71, with an intermediate shelf around the $112–$114 area where the stock has stabilized in late September, while resistance is anchored at the 52-week high of $142.40 and secondary resistance near the August peak of $136.75. A decisive break above $136–$142 would signal that the turnaround narrative has regained market sponsorship and could open a move toward new highs, whereas a breakdown below $112 would expose the $98–$100 zone and ultimately the $84.71 low, threatening the 1-year uptrend. Volatility risk is comparatively contained — beta of 0.662 means DLTR is roughly 34% less volatile than SPY, which supports smaller position-sizing adjustments but also means the stock lacks the high-beta torque that drives sharp momentum rallies; the maximum drawdown of -38.53% nonetheless shows the stock can fall hard in adverse regimes.
Beta
0.66
0.66x market volatility
Max Drawdown
-38.5%
Largest decline past year
52-Week Range
$85-$142
Price range past year
Annual Return
+24.3%
Cumulative gain past year
| Period | DLTR Return | S&P 500 |
|---|---|---|
| 1m | -15.0% | +0.6% |
| 3m | -9.6% | +3.3% |
| 6m | +3.4% | +17.4% |
| 1y | +24.3% | +15.0% |
| ytd | -12.2% | +12.9% |
Bobby - Your AI Investment Partner
Get real-time data, AI-driven personalized investment analysis to make smarter investment decisions
DLTR Fundamental Analysis
Revenue is growing at a healthy clip: Q1 FY2026 (quarter ended May 2, 2026) revenue was $4.976 billion, up 7.24% year-over-year from $4.640 billion in Q1 FY2025, and the trailing multi-quarter trend shows sequential stability around $4.75–$5.45 billion with Q4 FY2025 at $5.451 billion. The single reported segment, Dollar Tree at $4.971 billion, essentially constitutes the entire top line following the Family Dollar divestiture, meaning growth now depends entirely on the core banner's multi-price rollout, private-label penetration, and new-store openings. With full-year estimated revenue of $25.03 billion (range $24.72–$25.29 billion), the growth trajectory implies low-to-mid single-digit expansion, consistent with a mature discount retailer rather than a high-growth story — the investment case therefore rests on margin and earnings leverage rather than revenue acceleration.
Profitability has improved materially and is the core of the bull thesis: Q1 FY2026 net income was $347.3 million with a net margin of 6.98%, gross margin of 36.87%, and operating margin of 9.51%, versus Q1 FY2025 net income of $343.4 million on a 7.40% net margin and 35.62% gross margin. Gross margin has expanded from 34.43% in Q2 FY2025 to 35.89% in Q3 FY2025, 39.17% in Q4 FY2025, and 36.87% in Q1 FY2026, a clear upward trajectory driven by multi-price mix, private label, and lower shrink; the company's trailing gross margin of 36.40% and operating margin of 8.23% are respectable for discount retail, where thin single-digit operating margins are typical. The prior-year Q4 FY2025 GAAP loss of -$3.696 billion (EPS -$17.18) reflects the Family Dollar impairment/divestiture charges rather than operating deterioration, and the subsequent return to consistent profitability ($506.1 million net income in Q4 FY2025, $347.3 million in Q1 FY2026) confirms the earnings base is now clean and improving.
Balance sheet and cash flow are adequate but not fortress-like: debt-to-equity is elevated at 1.879x, the current ratio is a thin 1.067, and cash flow to debt is only 0.085, indicating meaningful leverage relative to internally generated cash. Free cash flow is solid at $1.558 billion TTM, with Q1 FY2026 FCF of $391.1 million on operating cash flow of $644.0 million and capex of $252.9 million, and ROE is a strong 34.16% (though flattered by leverage and a smaller equity base after buybacks). The company returned capital aggressively — $585.8 million of stock repurchased and $500 million of debt repaid in Q1 FY2026 alone — funded by cash on hand of $1.051 billion, which supports the earnings-per-share story but leaves less cushion; with a 0% dividend yield and payout ratio, all shareholder return flows through buybacks, making FCF durability critical to the thesis.
Quarterly Revenue
$4.9B
2026-08
Revenue YoY Growth
+7.0%
YoY Comparison
Gross Margin
42.9%
Latest Quarter
Free Cash Flow
$1.9B
Last 12 Months
Revenue & Net Income Trends (2 Years)
Revenue Breakdown
Open an Account, get $2 TSLA now!
Valuation Analysis: Is DLTR Overvalued?
Because DLTR is profitable (Q1 FY2026 net income of $347.3 million, TTM EPS positive), the PE ratio is the appropriate primary metric: the stock trades at a trailing PE of 18.91x and a forward PE of 14.42x, a roughly 24% discount between trailing and forward multiples. That gap implies the market expects meaningful earnings growth — consistent with consensus FY EPS estimates of $8.39 versus the current run-rate — and the forward multiple of 14.4x is undemanding in absolute terms for a retailer with expanding gross margins and a credible turnaround. The PS ratio of 1.25x and EV/EBITDA of 12.92x provide corroborating context, with the EV/EBITDA multiple reflecting the company's debt load.
Relative to the broader market and sector, DLTR screens cheap: a trailing PE of 18.91x and forward PE of 14.42x compare favorably to the S&P 500's typical low-20s multiple, and the 1.25x PS ratio is modest for a consumer defensive name with 36.4% gross margins and a 6.6% net margin. The PEG ratio of -0.13 is not meaningful given the prior-year GAAP loss distorts the growth denominator, so it should be disregarded; instead, the forward PE of 14.4x against estimated EPS growth from a depressed base suggests the premium/discount debate is really about execution risk rather than valuation richness. On balance, DLTR trades at a discount to the market and to higher-quality defensive peers, which is justified by its thin 8.2% operating margin, 1.88x debt-to-equity, and the execution uncertainty embedded in the turnaround.
Historical context reinforces the "cheap but not distressed" read: DLTR's PE has ranged from roughly 11.6x (Q4 FY2025) to over 40x in loss-affected or low-earnings quarters, and the current 18.9x trailing sits in the middle-to-lower portion of that band, while the PS ratio of 1.25x is near the low end of its multi-year range (versus 3.7x–6.3x in FY2024–FY2025 periods when the share count and price base differed). The PB ratio of 6.44x is elevated versus historical levels near 4–6x, reflecting the reduced equity base after buybacks rather than a premium multiple on fundamentals. Net-net, the stock is not priced for perfection — the forward PE of 14.4x and PS of 1.25x suggest the market is assigning a meaningful probability to execution disappointment, leaving room for multiple expansion if margin gains and guidance raises continue.
PE
18.9x
Latest Quarter
vs. Historical
Low-End
5-Year PE Range 12x~42x
vs. Industry Avg
N/A
Industry PE ~N/A*
EV/EBITDA
12.9x
Enterprise Value Multiple
Investment Risk Disclosure
Financial and operational risks center on leverage and cash-flow coverage. Debt-to-equity of 1.879x is high for a discount retailer, the current ratio of 1.067 leaves almost no working-capital cushion, and cash flow to debt of just 0.085 means it would take over a decade of current operating cash flow to retire debt. The company returned $585.8 million via buybacks and repaid $500 million of debt in Q1 FY2026, leaving cash of $1.051 billion; if free cash flow of $1.558 billion TTM were to compress on margin pressure or capex acceleration, the buyback-driven EPS story would weaken materially. Revenue concentration is now total — the single Dollar Tree segment generated $4.971 billion of the $4.976 billion Q1 FY2026 top line — so any misstep in the core banner's multi-price rollout has no offsetting segment.
Market and competitive risks are amplified by the stock's recent relative weakness and valuation sensitivity. DLTR trails SPY by 23.78 percentage points year-to-date and 15.04 points over six months, and its beta of 0.662 means it will not rally as hard as the market in a risk-on rotation, while still participating in defensive-sector drawdowns. The forward PE of 14.42x is cheap versus the S&P 500's low-20s multiple, but that discount is justified by an 8.23% operating margin and 1.88x leverage; if peers like Dollar General or Five Below cut prices more aggressively, or if mass merchants like Walmart sharpen their value messaging, DLTR's traffic could erode further. Recent news highlights that the Q2 earnings beat was overshadowed by store-expansion concerns, and tariff-refund reinvestment is a finite lever that cannot be repeated indefinitely.
Worst-case scenario: a consumer slowdown combines with tariff-driven cost inflation and a botched store-expansion cycle, causing gross margin to roll back toward the 34.43% Q2 FY2025 level and foot traffic to decline, which would pressure EPS below the $8.39 consensus and force analysts toward the $98 low target. From the current $114.07, that represents roughly -14%, and a deeper de-rating toward the 52-week low of $84.71 would be about -25.7%. The stock's maximum drawdown of -38.53% shows that in an adverse regime — for example, a recession that hits discretionary variety sales (45% of the mix) while fixed costs remain — losses from current levels could realistically reach -25% to -35%, with the $84.71 low as the anchor for the most severe outcome.
FAQ
Ranked by severity: first, financial leverage — debt-to-equity of 1.879x, a 1.067 current ratio, and cash flow to debt of only 0.085 leave little cushion if free cash flow compresses below the $1.558 billion TTM level. Second, momentum and sentiment — the stock is down 13.70% in a month and trails SPY by 23.78 points year-to-date, and a break below the $112 support shelf would expose the $98 low target and potentially the $84.71 52-week low. Third, competitive and macro pressure — 45% of sales are discretionary variety merchandise, which is vulnerable in a consumer slowdown, and tariff-driven cost inflation could reverse the gross-margin gains. Fourth, execution risk — the entire top line now depends on the single Dollar Tree segment, and store-expansion missteps or a failed multi-price rollout would have no offsetting segment.
The 12-month forecast has three scenarios: a base case (50% probability) targeting $125–$136.40 as gross margin holds at 36–37% and buybacks deliver EPS accretion toward $8.39; a bull case (25%) targeting $142.40–$170 if margin exceeds 38% and traffic turns positive, driving a re-rating toward 20x forward earnings; and a bear case (25%) targeting $84.71–$98 if margin falls below 35% and traffic declines, pushing EPS below consensus. The base case is most likely, anchored on the assumption that tariff-refund reinvestment offsets cost pressure and free cash flow stays above $1.5 billion. The key swing factor is whether the next quarterly print shows gross margin above 36% with stabilizing foot traffic.
DLTR screens undervalued on most metrics: the 14.42x forward PE is a 24% discount to the 18.91x trailing multiple and well below the S&P 500's low-20s, while the 1.25x PS ratio is near the low end of its multi-year range and the 12.92x EV/EBITDA reflects the debt load. The 6.44x PB ratio is elevated versus historical levels near 4–6x, but that reflects the reduced equity base after buybacks rather than a premium on fundamentals. The market is pricing in meaningful execution risk — the forward PE implies the market expects EPS to grow toward $8.39, and the $98 low target suggests a 14% downside if that fails. Relative to peers and its own history, DLTR is fairly valued to modestly undervalued, with multiple expansion potential if margin gains continue.
From a risk/reward perspective, DLTR is a reasonable but not compelling buy at $114.07: the 19.6% upside to the $136.40 average analyst target is attractive, and the 14.42x forward PE is cheap, but the 25.7% downside to the $84.71 52-week low and the 13.70% one-month decline mean the near-term risk is real. The stock is best suited for investors who believe the gross-margin recovery (34.43% to 36.87% year-over-year) is durable and who can tolerate a wide $98–$170 analyst target range. It is a good buy for patient value investors with a 12–18 month horizon, particularly on pullbacks toward the $112 support shelf, but less so for momentum traders given the 14.39-point one-month underperformance versus SPY. The biggest downside risk is a traffic slowdown combined with tariff cost pressure pushing EPS below the $8.39 consensus.
DLTR is better suited for long-term holding than short-term trading: the turnaround thesis — gross margin recovery, multi-price rollout, and buyback-driven EPS growth — needs several quarters to play out, and the 0% dividend yield means there is no income to compensate for short-term volatility. Beta of 0.662 means the stock is roughly 34% less volatile than SPY, which reduces the appeal for short-term momentum traders, while the 13.70% one-month decline shows it can still fall sharply in adverse regimes. Earnings visibility is moderate, with 25 analysts covering the stock but a wide $98–$170 target range, suggesting quarterly prints will drive sharp moves. A minimum holding period of 12–18 months is appropriate to capture the margin and buyback story, with position sizing disciplined around the $112 support and $136–$142 resistance levels.